Only the State can run social services
Posted on December 31st, 2016
What distinguishes left and right and what is the balance between them. Why are political issues are so divisive?
I am drawn to the left because I believe that certain services and projects such as education, health, infrastructure and defense can only be achieved by government.
The right argues that these services can be achieved by private enterprise. I question therefore what is the point of the state if not to organise collective social projects. And if the state does not organise collective projects then the state shrinks to nothing and there is ultimately no country and no society.
We may institute competition in the health service but it should only be to drive down cost not quality. This is justified only if competition makes organisations waste less, but not if it makes them cut corners and lower standards. The standards in the health service should be the highest and we should be prepared to pay for them. The state is the guarantor of fairness and equality.
Society needs a glue to hold it together. A set of values, common beliefs, upheld by justice and law. This is the basis for civilisation and for society as we know it. Otherwise we would return to the survival of the strongest, the fittest, the meanest, the most violent as in the middle ages. We have come a long way since, having understood the importance of human rights to oppose anarchy and to support the equal rights of all.
Socialism is built on these notions of equality, to give people equal opportunities, even if it is not possible for all people to achieve the same heights. Not all people have the same intellect or capacity to achieve, but society offers its underwritten protection to the weakest to achieve to the best of each person's highest abilities and so contribute to the whole.
By its nature therefore the basis of socialism is that the strongest support the weak. But let us not confuse socialism with the centrally planned economies of the Soviet Union which put aside individual freedom on pain of punishment. This is not a caring society.